Pages
ZX Complex Flow Solver Wind Lidar Installation ZX Lidars Vacancy Careers UK Wind Lidar Production Centre Doppler Lidar ZX Measurement Services History of Lidar Order online today Use Cases Error 404 Bankability UK Remote Sensing Test Site Publications Gallery News and Events Trusted Service Providers Privacy Policy Legal Contact Client login Wind Lidars About us Home
Posts
Turbine validation underway at Galloper Offshore Wind Farm Wind data displaces 245 million tonnes of CO2 Senvion chief joins ZX Lidars to spearhead turbine Lidar tech ZX Lidars' North American Service & Support Center opens with NRG Systems Deutsche WindGuard unlocks complex wind sites with ZX Lidars Go ahead for Greek giant as Istos launches wind measurement campaign with Lidar ZX Lidars excels at wind measurements in complex terrain Siemens Gamesa Renewable Energy approves ZX TM for Power Performance Testing UL and ZX Lidars place industry focus on wind farm performance validation Tunisia tackles wind energy with wind Lidar Green light for GreenGo Lidars in Italy for wind projects Remote restart to wind projects impacted by COVID Wind Lidar #307 - 10 years on NRG Systems now offering ZX Lidars worldwide via Global Network Permanent Met Lidars at Irish Wind Farms Vestas turbines to feature nacelle-based wind Lidar The original wind Lidar, now available from NRG Systems RES sends in Lidars for Australian wind development ZX Lidars achieves world-first wind Lidar measurements from a drone Lidar lights up wind opportunities for Tilt in Australia New turbine-mounted Lidar and formation of Measurement Services business Canadian grid moves from masts to Lidars on operational wind farms ZephIR Lidar Achieves Full IEC Compliance Inch Cape completes 3-year wind measurements with Lidar ZephIR Lidar Wind Lidar Workshop - Okinawa, Japan 22nd June 2018 We're exhibiting at Global Offshore Wind 2018 EOLOS success offshore increases Lidar demand Mike Anderson shines light on ZephIR Lidar ZephIR Lidar MD saddles up for ‘Ride Africa: Kenya' to raise funds for Child.org SOCRATES meets ZephIR as Lidar project sets sail to inform global warming strategy Floating Lidar company EOLOS to deploy with ZephIR in Baltic Sea Wind farm offshore substations get Lidar upgrade Wind farm operator SSE Generation opts for wind Lidar, permanently Smartec sends ZephIR Lidar in to the Taipei Basin with the National Taiwan University ZephIR Lidar expands Engineering Team following establishment of new UK Lidar Production Centre DNV GL verifies nacelle-mounted ZephIR Lidar wind measurements Largest dedicated Wind Lidar Production Centre in Europe established, with global outreach REG Power Management Lifting Construction Safety Standards with Lidar Hundreds gather at launch of powerful ‘CFD + Lidar’ combination for more effective wind measurements in complex terrain New IEC standard sees acceptance for wind lidars in wind turbine power curve testing Industry-reviewed procedure for measuring wind turbine power curves with CW lidar released Dulas launches met mast verification service with ZephIR 300 wind lidar Wake steering results in 15% power increase in 'total wind farm control' demonstration ORE Catapult, RES and Centrica tackle blade erosion with ZephIR DM to uplift turbine production by up to 2% EnergieKontor pro-actively reduce future wind farm uncertainty with ZephIR Lidar. Vestas confirms use of ZephIR Lidar on multi-rotor concept demonstrator ZephIR 300 promotes safe-lifting on jack-up vessel at Block Island Offshore Wind Farm Smartec secure ZephIR Lidar sales in Taiwanese wind market Smartec and ZephIR Lidar inform Taiwanese market on the developing applications of wind lidar New European Wind Atlas program to benefit from ZephIR 300 wind measurements, with Uppsala University ZephIR Lidar Wind Lidar Workshop - Beijing 2016 ZephIR Lidar replaces met mast and goes SCADA-integrated with Senvion at Infinis wind farm Goldwind uses ZephIR Lidar for optimisation, certification & control of 6MW turbine New lidar-based turbine power performance and optimisation service launched in Europe Dogger Bank lidar confirms technology meets met masts for wind data collection DNV GL signs framework deal demonstrating IEC compliance of ZephIR 300 wind lidar EDF adopt ZephIR wind lidar technology to optimise wind farm performance New offshore wind lidar launched – ZephIR 300M (for Marine!) Infinis chooses ZephIR Lidar to optimise operational site performance Leading renewable energy company RES signs framework agreement with ZephIR Lidar European Funding brings ZephIR 300 wind lidar to Malta Ammonit delivers fleet of wind lidars to Central European wind energy market Consultancy demonstrates wind lidar accuracy in wind farm complex terrain, set to phase out masts EOLOS floating buoy featuring ZephIR 300 wind lidar scoops innovation award World-first and new standard achieved in floating lidar as AXYS selects ZephIR 300 270 MW Lincs Offshore Wind Farm gets boost with ZephIR Lidar Cornell University deploys dual ZephIR 300 wind lidars for more accurate turbulence study for wind turbines Babcock’s FORECAST Floating ZephIR LiDAR reaches Stage 2 of Carbon Trust OWA roadmap The lowest cost of finance-grade ‘hub-height and above’ wind data available – that’s ZephIR Direct Dulas to acquire fleet of ZephIR Lidars for rental to UK wind market World first as Canadian WindEEE wind dome deploys DTU / ZephIR WindScanner Industry expert report demonstrates ZephIR 300 as ‘bankable’ onshore and offshore, in complex sites and on floating platforms Fraunhofer IWES Wind Lidar Buoy Verified at FINO1 Industry’s highest level of wind lidar infield support launched at UK’s leading wind event, renewableUK 2014 US Strides Forward with Lidar Controlled Turbine - Achieved with NREL, DNV GL, University of Stuttgart and ZephIR Lidar Inch Cape Offshore Limited Lights Up Wind Farm with ZephIR Lidar, Supported by SgurrEnergy ZephIR DM moving closer to new international power curve standard Lidar Research Programme 1st project announcement: Novel combined floating lidar + mast using the expertise of research institute CRES, floating mast company FloatMast and industry leading wind lidar ZephIR 300. Largest batch of single-type lidar verifications against an IEC-compliant met mast released by ZephIR Lidar After 40 months continuous operation ZephIR demonstrates long-term performance stability of continuous wave lidar with no requirement for re-calibration Ammonit partners with ZephIR Lidar as a Trusted Service Provider Gaelectric deploy duo of consultancies, and leading lidar provider, ZephIR, and sees increase of 2% on P90/P50 for the long-term energy production expected to be achieved at its 42 MW Dunbeg Wind Farm. RES ZephIR Lidar Research Programme launched for Research Institutes DNV GL: ZephIR 300 wind lidar is accepted for use in bankable / finance-grade wind speed and energy assessments with either no or limited on-site met mast comparisons under ZephIR 300 verified against IEC compliant Lelystad met mast Turbine-mounted ZephIR Lidar at forefront of pioneering RES and Vestas study Vince Cable presents ZephIR Lidar with Institute of Physics Innovation Award ZephIR Lidar signs new Chinese distribution agreement, presents at China Windpower Babcock chooses ZephIR for pioneering floating lidar system ZephIR Lidar win prestigious Institute of Physics Innovation Award NEL deploys ZephIR 300 to steer industry guidance on power curve measurements, turbine micro-siting with CFD modelling, and to verify load measurements on key wind turbine components ZephIR Lidar Scientist To Deliver Lecture at Europe World-first simultaneous measurements upwind and downwind from a wind turbine delivered by ZephIR Dual Mode to DTU Wind Energy (Ris Vestas deploys multiple ZephIR Lidars at largest wind power project in the Southern Hemisphere ZephIR Lidar expected to play significant role in Chinese offshore wind projects Single most comprehensive set of remote sensing test results against an IEC compliant met mast spanning almost 80 trials over a two year period, released today by ZephIR Lidar TuuliSaimaa deploy ZephIR lidar during construction of wind farm ensuring safe operations Ten years at the top, measuring right to the top, with ZephIR Lidar Ecofys release positioning statement stating improved bankability with ZephIR 300 wind lidar, and point to inclusion in new IEC standards for power curve measurements ZephIR Presentation at Windpower Monthly Five papers from the ZephIR team presented at EWEA, Vienna Raedthuys Group to deploy ZephIR lidar on mass across portfolio of sites ZephIR 300 approved for use as stand-alone resource assessment by the Energy research Centre for the Netherlands REG Windpower deploys ZephIR lidar to close MASDAR OF ABU DHABI PROCURES TWO ZEPHIR 300 WIND LIDARS TO SUPPORT RENEWABLE ENERGY DEVELOPMENT IN THE UAE ZEPHIR LTD AWARDED ISO 9001:2008 CERTIFICATION BY BM TRADA CAMPBELL SCIENTIFIC SELECTS ZEPHIR WIND LIDAR TECHNOLOGY FOR US WIND MARKET NATURAL POWER RELEASES RESULTS FROM FIRST ZEPHIR 300 BATCH SHOWING HIGH LEVELS OF ACCURACY ACROSS THE BOARD Natural Power deploys first dual-mode ZephIR wind lidar in India with the Centre for Wind Energy Technology Natural Power's ZephIR wind lidar demonstrates world-first matched performance in wind tunnel ZephIR establishes global network of Trusted Service Providers - www.zephirlidar.com ZephIR 300 installed at Dogger Bank offshore wind farm with Forewind Natural Power business ZephIR aligns with remote power specialists Ampair ZephIR 300 Heralds New Era for Wind Lidar ZephIR Lidar Deployed in Support of Narec Offshore Demonstrator Project ZephIR - RERL approved for measurements in the wind industry
 
 

ZX Complex Flow Solver

 
Home » ZX Complex Flow Solver

Introduction

Since October 2012 the DNV GL ‘Stage 3’ statement in the Roadmap for Remote Sensing Devices (RSDs) has allowed for a standalone ZX 300 wind Lidar (i.e. no need for an onsite met mast) to be used for finance-grade (commonly referred as ‘bankable’) Energy Yield Analysis in the support of onshore wind farm development in simple, non-complex terrain.

Announced in January 2021 based on a broad evidence base, an industry collaboration has developed a ‘Complex Flow Solver’ that combines 50-point Continuous Wave Lidar measurements, high resolution open source Computational Fluid Dynamic modelling and powerful cloud computing to deliver ‘the best available solution for bankable wind resource and energy yield assessment based on standalone Lidar’ in complex terrain and unlocks the use of ZX 300 without the need for a met mast in any type of terrain onshore. The use of ZX CFS is approved by Deutsche WindGuard.

The details

All current commercial RSDs assume homogenous flow across the volume from which the measurement samples are taken. For the majority of Use Cases this assumption is valid and a wide body of evidence supports this assumption as is evidenced by more than 500 Performance Verifications of ZX 300 units at the UK Remote Sensing Test Site:

Height (m) Gradient R2
(m) Mean Std Dev Mean Std Dev
91 1.002 0.007 0.990 0.006
70 1.001 0.005 0.992 0.006
45 1.000 0.005 0.993 0.006
20 0.998 0.005 0.993 0.006

Table 1: Regression analysis of wind speed from > 500 ZX300 performance verifications from the UK RSTS

In complex terrain depending on the location of the Lidar this assumption can either still be valid or become invalid in the same way that if were possible to move a met mast across a complex site it would provide different wind measurements with only very small movements particularly if you were, for example, on the side of a hill. In cases where the assumption of homogenous flow is no longer valid, any Lidar measurement will differ when compared to a met mast that is in the same location and to date, this difference has resulted in the use of standalone Lidar to be limited as the onsite validation and therefore traceability of measurements is not available. The benefits of Lidar in complex terrain – portability, cost, planning, H&S – can be lost and it is this that drives the need for change and a new solution to address the challenge.

Figure 2: Left to right: homogenous flow in flat terrain; another example of homogenous flow in complex terrain, and; non-homogenous flow in complex terrain

Traditional cup anemometry itself also shows different responses to conditions such as inflow angles and turbulence (Albers et al., DEWI-Magazine 18, February 2001). This adds to the challenges of comparing RSDs with their own dependencies to these cups but as noted above the industry still demands this traceability, for now.

A white box approach born from industry collaboration

Full transparency and the understanding of any post-processing of data is essential in delivering any solution to using Lidar standalone in complex terrain and the challenge is well documented in IEC 61400-12-1 Ed 2 L.4.5 ‘Uncertainty due to non-homogenous flow within the measurement volume’ which states that the combination of a suitable flow model and a model reproducing the remote sensing device horizontal wind speed extraction algorithm might be used to assess the uncertainty due to non-homogenous flow.

Consideration of non-homogenous flow can legitimately be undertaken by detailed CFD analysis and results in the derivation of ‘conversion factors’ for Lidar measurements. Comprehensive analysis and documentation of the situation provides all info relevant for a bankable wind assessment. The uncertainty associated with the impact of complex flow on the Lidar measurement is reduced and replaces the otherwise more conservative Mann-Bingöl assessment of uncertainty and provides the input necessary for third-party bankable assessments.

Deutsche WindGuard, ZephyScience and ZX Lidars have collaborated to deliver the ‘ZX Complex Flow Solver’ (ZX CFS) that operates in this way; converting ZX Lidar data to be representative of a point / cup-equivalent measurement and in doing so providing a clear reduction of measurement uncertainty and data that can be used for bankable energy assessments in the development of wind farms.

High resolution CFD modelling

ZX CFS solves the three-dimensional flows using OpenFOAM[1], which is a flexible CFD toolbox and is applied world-wide for various purposes, including automotive and wind energy applications. The fully automated flow model provides a numerical solution of the steady-state Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes Equations, modelling turbulence using the RNG-k-ε turbulence closure model, which is a widely applied and validated model describing turbulent transport and dissipation. OpenFOAM has the particular advantage of offering a parallelized unstructured calculation solver, which allows complex topographies to be resolved with more efficiency and with higher resolution. In order to detect small scale effects, a horizontal resolution of the calculation mesh of just 10 metres is applied with a synoptical resolution of 10°.

During calculations for the Bolund Case[2], which is the most comprehensive systematical flow model comparison for wind energy purposes performed to date, three out of the top five results (from all 50 participating models) were calculated by the model OpenFOAM.

This high resolution CFD model is made accessible to users through the ZephyFarm platform[3] – a front-end web-browser client application, powered by cloud computing to allow conversion factors to be produced for each Lidar deployment in ~1hr.

ZX Complex Flow Solver approach

The basic steps for running ZX CFS are defined as:

  1. User uploads to ZephyFarm portal:
    1. Lidar wind data measurement file; or
    2. Lidar location & measurement heights (if a. is considered too sensitive or for pre-deployment site assessment)
  2. Outputs include:
    1. A Conversion Intensity Map for the optimisation of Lidar siting before deployment which minimises project uncertainty as much as possible and is a useful, perhaps essential, element of considering project value before any actual measurement campaign commences.
    2. Conversion factors to be applied to 10-minute wind speed data (user then simply multiplies wind speed by the conversion factor, which is a function measurement height and direction)
    3. Converted data (if original Lidar data is uploaded)
  3. Deutsche WindGuard provides approval (with quantified uncertainties) for use of standalone Lidar data in complex terrain.

Validation and Impact

Over the past 12 months, well-instrumented sites have been assessed using ZX CFS to convert the installed ZX 300 wind data and compare the obtained results to that of the collocated cup-instrumented meteorological mast. ZX CFS Validation results demonstrate an improvement in agreement between the ZX 300 Lidar and masts in complex terrain. There is a clear removal of the bias caused by non-homogenous flow. In addition, no boundaries in the use of ZX CFS have been found to date. The correlation coefficient (the statistical relationship between the two) can be seen to improve towards unity in the vast majority of cases. An in-depth review of the validations focussed on various sites where all cup calibration documentation was available and in addition to the correlation improvement, an improvement in regression was also achieved.

Conclusions

Through careful validation by independent wind engineering company Deutsche WindGuard, ZX Complex Flow Solver (CFS) appropriately addresses the challenges of using Lidar in complex terrain and provides a solution for bankable wind resource and EYA based on a standalone ZX Lidar. The use of ZX CFS is approved by Deutsche WindGuard.

This study builds on previous work in this area including:

  • Post conversion of Lidar data on complex terrains, Sanquer, Woodward – Meteodyn, ZephIR Lidar
  • Uncertainty of CFD-adjusted lidar measurements, Marmander, Abiven, Juguet – Natural Power
  • Validated adjustment of remote sensing bias in complex terrain using CFD – Harris, Locker, Douglas, Girault, Abiven, Brady – Natural Power

[1] The OpenFOAM Foundation: OpenFOAM 8.0; 2020; www.openfoam.org

[2] CFD+engineering: The Bolund Case – Comparison of Simulation Results with Measured Data, Version 1.0.0 , 08/2010.

[3] ZephyFarm – Wind Farm Engineering Solutions; zephyfarm.io

The solution is described in detail in the following 1hr webinar:

Sign up to our newsletter
This site uses cookies.
Configure
 
Read our privacy policy

You can read more about our privacy policy here.